|
|
|
|

|
|
Homeopathy |
| Consider This
Therapy For |
| Homeopathic remedies are extremely
diluted solutions (usually 1 part per
million or less) of assorted herbs, animal
products, and chemicals. Indeed, the vast
majority are so diluted that it's
impossible to detect the original active
ingredient in laboratory tests.
This leads to a certain amount of
confusion. Many people tend to think of
homeopathic products as herbal remedies
when, in fact, they contain little if any
of the desired herb. According to
homeopathic practitioners, the solutions
do continue to hold a "trace memory" of
the original substance. Mainstream
scientists, however, find them completely
devoid of any meaningful amount of
medicine.
What, then, can homeopathic remedies do
for you? As far as science can determine,
the answer is Nothing. On the other hand,
advocates of this therapy say that
clinical research has shown certain
homeopathic medicines to be more effective
than a placebo (dummy pill) in the
treatment of seasonal allergies, asthma,
and influenza. Proponents also claim
verified benefits for a variety of other
conditions, from easing labor and
childbirth to speeding the healing of a
sprained ankle. Still, these claims have
yet to be confirmed by the kind of
broad-based, carefully controlled testing
demanded for other types of medication.
There are literally thousands of
homeopathic remedies, and their alleged
benefits cover just about every disease
symptom imaginable. Since they are as safe
as bottled water (in fact, often are
bottled water), there's no harm in trying
them for relief of annoying conditions
such as colds, flu, headache, and
indigestion. It would be unwise, however,
to use them as the sole remedy for any
serious medical condition. Not only would
you be foregoing the possibility of a
speedy cure when faced with an ailment
like an infection, you'd also be risking
dangerous complications when suffering
from progressive conditions like heart
disease and cancer. |
| How the
Treatments Are Done |
| Homeopathic medicines are available
without a prescription, so anyone can read
up on the remedies suggested for a
particular symptom, buy them, and try them
on their own. If you visit a homeopathic
practitioner, however, you'll be
introduced to a whole
"through-the-looking-glass" approach to
medicine unlike anything in standard
health care.
A homeopathic practitioner (who may be
a physician, chiropractor, or unlicensed
entrepreneur) typically begins by taking a
lengthy medical history, including
detailed information on an individual's
temperament, preferences in diet and
lifestyle, and emotional state. From these
findings, a "classical" homeopathic
practitioner will build a "symptom
picture" against which to match
homeopathy's extensive array of remedies.
More eclectic (or opportunistic)
practitioners may also employ props such
as "electrodiagnostic devices" that beep
and give read-outs when a probe is pressed
to the skin.
Remedies (in the form of alcohol or
water solutions or sugar pills) are
usually prescribed one at a time, although
they may be combined. Homeopathic
practitioners may rely solely on
homeopathy, or may complement this
approach with standard medicine or other
alternative therapies such as naturopathy.
For instance, a homeopathic physician
might try homeopathic remedies to relieve
a child's ear infection, turning to
antibiotics only if the homeopathic
products fail to work a cure. |
| What Treatment
Hopes to Accomplish |
| Homeopathy was developed around 1800
by Samuel Hahnemann, a German physician.
At the time, it was a welcome alternative
to the damaging and ineffective practices
of traditional medicine, which included
blood-letting, application of leeches, and
purging with high doses of
life-threatening substances, including
mercury and lead.
At the turn of the 19th century, little
was known about the causes of disease, so
Hahnemann focused on the symptoms instead.
Noting that cinchona, a malaria remedy,
produced malaria-like symptoms when taken
by a healthy volunteer, Hahnemann
concluded that "like cures like": A
substance that causes certain symptoms
should also relieve them. He then
proceeded to test a vast number of plant,
animal, and mineral substances on himself
and others in a procedure called
"proving," observing the symptoms they
produced and categorizing them as cures
for disorders that cause similar troubles.
The idea that like cures like wasn't
new; it had been suggested by the ancient
Greek physician Hippocrates, among others.
But Hahnemann added a twist called the
"Law of Infinitesimals." Because large
doses of many remedies were quite
poisonous, he began to experiment with
smaller and smaller amounts, ultimately
coming to believe that minute doses were
actually more effective. Hence it became a
tenet of homeopathy that the more diluted
a substance is, the more powerful its
healing action will be.
To maximize the effect of his remedies,
Hahnemann therefore invented a system for
"potentizing" them. Each substance was
repeatedly diluted and shaken until, at
the "higher" potencies, not one molecule
of the original substance remained. For
example, a homeopathic remedy labeled
"12X" has been diluted by a factor of ten,
12 times in a row, to produce a dilution
of 1 part in a trillion.
Since it's impossible for such a
solution to have any physical effect,
homeopaths ascribe the therapeutic action
of their remedies to an "essence,"
"memory," or "energy imprint" that can
mobilize the body's "vital forces."
Medical science, on the other hand,
attributes any relief either to
coincidence (when an illness runs its
course) or the placebo effect (the power
of suggestion).
Despite the implausibility of
homeopathic theories, results of clinical
research have not been entirely negative.
In 1997, an international team of
researchers reviewed over 100 controlled
studies that had claimed positive results
from homeopathy. The team deemed 26 of
these experiments to have been designed
and carried out according to the most
rigorous standards. By themselves, none of
these studies showed homeopathy to be
clearly effective. However, when taken as
a group, they seemed to indicate that
homeopathy produced somewhat greater
benefit than placebo.
Noting the lack of any scientific
theory to explain the results, the team
simply said they showed the need for more
intensive research. Some baffled
scientists commented that if
placebo-controlled clinical trials could
show some effectiveness for homeopathy,
then the trials themselves must be subject
to as-yet-unidentified bias on the part of
the researchers. Others simply ascribed
the results to luck, noting that if you
perform enough trials, a few will deliver
positive results merely by chance.
Proponents of homeopathy respond that
conventional medicine still uses a variety
of drugs that were shown effective by
trial and error long before their
mechanism of action was understood.
Homeopathic practitioners also point to
vaccination as an example of "like curing
like," and note that smaller doses of
certain standard drugs (such as aspirin to
prevent heart attack) are more effective
than larger doses. To critics, however,
these examples are irrelevant. Neither
aspirin nor vaccines would have any effect
if diluted to the strengths found in
homeopathic products. Furthermore, say
opponents, homeopathy's emphasis on
matching remedies to symptoms, and not to
underlying disease states, discards the
vast body of discoveries made since the
time when Hahnemann proposed his theory.
|
| Who Should Avoid
This Therapy? |
| If you choose to experiment with this
therapy, you can rest assured that it's
safe for virtually anyone, including
children. If you need to avoid alcohol,
however, you'll need to forego homeopathic
remedies with an alcohol base (tinctures).
|
| What Side
Effects May Occur? |
| Even placebos have been known to cause
side effects, so there's always a chance
that you could experience an adverse
reaction. For practical purposes, however,
the odds are very slim.
Unlike vitamins and herbal remedies,
which are sold as "dietary supplements,"
homeopathic remedies are marketed as
over-the-counter medications--but with a
unique exemption from standard regulatory
procedures. In 1938, U.S. Senator Royal
Copeland of New York--a leading
homeopath--included a special release for
homeopathic remedies in the landmark
Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act,
allowing them to be sold without proof of
safety. Today they continue to be marketed
without the evidence of safety and
efficacy required of other medications.
Their labels must, however, include
ingredients, directions, dilution, and at
least one indication (what the medication
is to be used for). |
| How to Choose a
Therapist |
| Homeopathy is practiced as an
acceptable medical discipline in many
nations, but is minimally regulated in the
United States. Homeopathic practitioners
may be medical doctors, osteopaths,
chiropractors, naturopathic physicians, or
other licensed medical professionals.
(They may also be unlicensed freelancers.)
They may be self-educated in homeopathy,
or may have undergone extensive training.
To avoid a potentially dangerous
misdiagnosis of your condition, it's best
to seek a licensed MD or DO.
The vast majority of homeopathic
remedies do not require a prescription, so
any motivated individual may in effect
become an amateur homeopath by consulting
reference books and taking remedies
available at health food stores,
pharmacies, or by mail order. In many
states, however, prescribing even
non-prescription medications (including
homeopathic ones) for other people without
a medical license is illegal. |
| When Should
Treatment Stop? |
| Some homeopathic remedies are
recommended for use every few hours during
an acute condition; others, for use on a
daily basis to support resistance to
disease or strengthen various aspects of
health. You can quickly tell whether the
remedy is relieving an acute condition,
and move on to other treatments if it
isn't. Remedies taken to improve
resistance are more insidious, since
there's no specific way to judge their
effect. |
| See a
Conventional Doctor If... |
| It's safe to take homeopathic remedies
for temporary symptoms of minor illness,
but don't rely on these products for
treatment of any serious illnesses or
injury. Even reputable homeopaths don't do
that; nor do they claim that homeopathy
can cure life-threatening conditions such
as cancer or diabetes. If your symptoms
persist or any new problems develop, see a
licensed physician for a conventional
diagnosis.
Although homeopathy is often
recommended as a "safe and gentle"
alternative therapy for children, always
keep in mind why it's so safe. If symptoms
such as diarrhea, headache, fever, or
abdominal pain fail to clear up, see a
doctor before the situation gets worse.
|
|
|
|
|
|