How common is depression in people with alcohol
problems?
- Up to 40 per cent of people
who drink heavily have symptoms that resemble a
depressive illness.
- However, when these same
people are not drinking heavily, only 5 per cent
of men and 10 per cent of woman have symptoms
meeting the diagnostic criteria for depression -
not that different from the rates of depression
in the general population.
- About 5 to 10 per cent of
people with a depressive illness also have
symptoms of an alcohol problem.
Why might alcohol
problems and depression occur together?
Alcohol can briefly produce a
pleasant and relaxed state of the mind. However,
alcohol problems and depression commonly occur
together. There are several reasons for this:
- both alcohol problems and
depression are extremely common. They may occur
together completely independently.
- people with depression
sometimes use alcohol as a form of
self-medication, for example either in an
attempt to cheer themselves up, or sometimes to
help them sleep. Although in small quantities
alcohol can briefly lift mood, if used to try to
cope with a depressive illness, problems arise.
Tolerance to the effects of alcohol can lead to
individuals needing it in larger quantities to
have an effect.
- alcohol in large quantities,
whether taken to treat a depression or not,
produces a depressant effect on people's mood.
Why is an alcohol
problem together with depression a particular
worry?
Alcohol compromises judgment
and makes people impulsive and likely to take
risks. Alcohol also causes a loss of inhibition
and increases aggressive behavior and violent
acts. Because increased alcohol consumption often
occurs together with a depressed mood, this is a
particular concern. Depression can lead to
thoughts of suicide. The lack of self-control,
compromised judgment and impulsivity from the
alcohol can increase the chances of a person
attempting suicide. Generally, a much higher
incidence of suicide, both completed and
attempted, is associated with alcohol.
The common problems of
depression and alcohol are frequently complicated
by social problems. Alcohol can often lead to
problems at work in the form of absenteeism,
sickness and under performance. The loss of a job
has a profound negative impact on a person's
financial status and family life. Marital problems
often arise because of an alcohol problem,
although it may be difficult to say which started
first.
Alcohol can also cause a large
number of physical problems. Few, if any organs in
the body are spared. Liver problems commonly arise
from heavy alcohol intake and can take the form of
jaundice (a yellow discoloration of the skin)
resulting from hepatitis, cirrhosis of the liver
or liver failure. Unchecked these will lead to
death. Other common problems include:
- stomach ulcers
- anemia
- an irregular heartbeat
- impotence.
Both alcohol intoxication and
withdrawal have a damaging effect on the brain,
and can cause:
- loss of sensation in the arms
or legs
- loss of muscle power
- profound memory disturbances
- a shrunken brain.
Although alcohol can cause you
to fall asleep, the quality of the sleep that
follows tends to be poor. This is why people with
depression should not use alcohol to try to
improve their sleep, since it will actually have
the opposite effect.
Excessive alcohol intake can
also lead to legal problems. These may result from
driving offences, drunk and disorderly behavior,
or violent crime due to the impulsivity and lack
of self-control caused by alcohol. Involvement
with the legal establishment does not tend to help
a depressed mood.
Alcohol problems account for:
- 33 per cent of domestic
accidents
- 40 per cent of fatal domestic
fires
- 15 to 30 per cent of
workplace accidents.
Depression is also associated
with an increased rate of accidents and so the
combination can be worrying.
Some antidepressants are
sedative. If they are taken with alcohol, a person
can be seriously sedated and at risk of their
breathing stopping. In addition, many
antidepressants are broken down in the liver.
Because alcohol can damage the liver, the levels
of these antidepressants in the body will be
higher in people who are also drinking heavily.
This can lead to an increase in side effects from
the antidepressants.
What causes the link
between alcohol and depression?
There are a number of ways in
which alcohol and depression may be linked.
Links with brain function
Over the last decade new
research has shed light on the way alcohol affects
the brain, and in the ways in which the brain is
affected in depression. It is now known that some
of the systems that are involved in producing the
symptoms of low mood, anxiety, poor sleep and
reduced appetite in depression are also affected
by alcohol. This is one explanation of why alcohol
can cause depression.
Psychosocial links
There are many potential
psychological and social reasons for links between
alcohol and depression.
- Stressful life events can
precipitate both alcohol problems and
depression.
- People with alcohol problems
report more incidences of neglect and poor
parenting as children than those without. These
factors may also increase the risk of developing
depression.
Genetic links
It is possible to inherit an
increased likelihood of both alcohol problems and
depression.
- Alcohol problems are more
frequent in the children of those who have
severe alcohol problems. It is difficult to know
what exactly is inherited. It could be a
tolerance (or lack of it) to the effects of
alcohol, or differences in the way alcohol
affects various systems in the brain.
- The genetic basis of
depression is also well established. It is well
known that having a first-degree relative (ie a
parent or sibling) with depression increases
your chances of having depression in later life.
- Studies of depressed patients
show that their relatives not only have an
increased risk of depression, but also a number
of other conditions including alcohol problems.
How much alcohol do you
need to drink to affect the brain?
Many of the effects of alcohol
on the systems of the brain depend on the 'dose'
of alcohol taken.
- At low doses (say one to two
units of alcohol), alcohol has a relaxing and
euphoric effect that makes a person feel
confident, more social and jovial.
- However, even small amounts
of alcohol (one to five units) produce poor
coordination, slowed reaction times and
increased risk taking.
- The legal driving limit in
the UK is 80mg of alcohol per 100ml of blood. It
is impossible to say exactly what this is in
units. This is because the concentration of
alcohol in the blood will depend on the size of
the person, how quickly they drink and many
other factors. On average, the legal limit will
be reached after drinking around three to five
units. But the legal driving limit is not a
'safe amount' of alcohol. Somebody with an
alcohol level of between 50 and 80mg (ie below
the legal limit) has a risk of a non-fatal
accident twice that of a sober driver and is six
times more likely to have a fatal accident.
- With levels of alcohol above
twice the legal driving limit, memory is
affected and seriously poor coordination starts
occurring.
- At three to four times the
legal driving limit, the breathing centre in the
brain can be affected leading to death.
These effects may occur at very
different blood alcohol concentrations in
different people because drinking alcohol produces
tolerance to its effects. This means that people
who regularly drink large quantities develop
effects at higher blood alcohol concentrations.
What is a safe amount to
drink?
Current recommendations are that
risks of problems (both physical and
psychological) are greatly increased in men
consuming more that 28 units of alcohol per week,
and women more than 21 units. A unit of alcohol
is:
- half a pint of beer
- half a pint of a lager or
cider (strong lagers and ciders can be up to two
units per half pint)
- a single pub measure of a
spirit (a 'home' measure can easily be three to
four units)
- a small glass of wine.
These recommendations are not a
'safe' limit - it is simply a level above which
the risks get significantly greater.
- 28 units (or 21 units for
women) consumed all at once is certainly not
safe and can cause serious problems.
- You should aim for at least
one or two days each week when you do not drink
any alcohol.
When should I be worried
if I have an alcohol problem?
There are a number of pointers
that should lead you to consider if you have an
alcohol problem. These include:
- using alcohol to try to
escape from your worries and troubles.
- using alcohol to help you
sleep.
- if you drink every day.
- if you are drinking more than
the recommended units a week.
- if having a drink starts
being one of the most important things in your
life.
- if you are regularly drinking
alone.
- if people are advising you to
cut down the amount you drink.
- if you get annoyed by people
criticising your drinking.
- if you feel guilty about
drinking.
- if you need a drink in the
morning to be able to face the world.
- if you feel shaky in the
morning after drinking heavily.
- if you have periods when you
were drinking that you cannot recall.
- if you have ever had problems
at work because of drink.
- if you have ever been
arrested or charged with any drink-related
offence.
How are alcohol problems
and depression treated?
Many of the symptoms reported by
people drinking heavily resemble those of
depression such as:
- fatigue
- disturbed sleep
- early morning waking
- poor energy levels
- poor appetite.
These are simply due to heavy
alcohol intake. This makes it difficult to be
clear if a person is suffering from an alcohol
problem plus depression or simply an alcohol
problem.
The situation is further
complicated because heavy alcohol intake can lead
to depression. As a result, it is normal practice
to deal with the alcohol problem first and see if
the depression gets better. If it does not, then
specific treatment for the depression would be
started.
Treatment with a serotonin
selective reuptake inhibitor (SSRI) antidepressant
can improve both depression and an alcohol
problem. This may point towards a common cause for
both disorders.
There are a number of things
that can be done to help people with alcohol
problems.
1. Detoxification to help a
person come off alcohol safely.
This involves the person
stopping all alcohol intake, usually covered by
the administration of medication such as diazepam
(Valium) or chlordiazepoxide (Librium) to prevent
a withdrawal syndrome.
Withdrawal symptoms include:
- tremor
- anxiety
- restlessness
- sweating
- nausea
- seizures
- delirium tremens (DTs).
DTs usually occur three days or
so after stopping alcohol and can last for up to
seven days. The symptoms of DTs include those
described above plus disorientation (being unaware
of where you are, what time, day or year it is,
and who other people are), hallucinations (seeing
or hearing things that are not there) and
delusions (having false beliefs about things,
especially being frightened of certain situations
and people).
2. Counselling
Support and counselling is used
to help the person achieve abstinence or
'controlled drinking' within safe limits. More
formal psychological therapies can be helpful,
such as cognitive behavioural therapy.
3. Medication
Occasionally, medication can be
helpful. This includes disulfiram (Antabuse) and
acamprosate (Campral). Disulfiram can aid
abstinence because it causes a person to have an
unpleasant, and potentially dangerous reaction, if
they drink while taking it. Acamprosate may help
to decrease the craving for alcohol. Both of these
medicines will only be helpful if the person
taking them is motivated to give up alcohol. They
are certainly not magic wands.
What should I do if I
think that I have developed an alcohol problem?
If you think you have a problem
with alcohol, you may well have managed the first
and hardest step in sorting it out - acknowledging
the problem to yourself. What you need to do now
is to speak to somebody about your concerns.
Support and help for alcohol problems can come
from a number of sources. These include:
- your GP.
- a counselor in your GP
practice.
- a local alcohol counseling
service (these are often advertised in GP
surgeries and can be found in the 'Counseling
and Advice' section of the Yellow Pages, and
under 'Alcohol' in the business section of The
Telephone Directory).
- Alcoholics Anonymous (can be
found in the business section of The Telephone
Directory).
- a drug and alcohol clinic run
by the local mental health services. You may be
able to self-refer, or you may need your GP to
refer you ask at your doctor's surgery.